- It really depends on who you ask when it comes to this question!
Frosted Blueberry Pop-Tarts
Blueberry was one of the original flavors of Pop Tarts to be released and they come in unfrosted as well, though you shouldn’t try those because who even wants an unfrosted Pop Tart? Most people say they like the frosted blueberry Pop Tarts and in fact, they have since they were kids. Others say these are hands down their favorite.
Pop-Tarts Oatmeal Delights
There are at least two kinds of these pastries including frosted strawberry and Mapley Brown Sugar. The mapley brown sugar Pop Tarts are a throwback to instant oatmeal packets, with a reasonable amount of filling and frosting. There are also cinnamon oat crumbles that look and taste good! For the strawberry version, some kids liked them better than the original strawberry Pop Tarts while others were not impressed, calling these Pop Tarts “the worst” and “beyond garbage.” Some say these are better than the original because of the oatmeal, that it “stays” with you a bit longer and keeps you a bit more full. Do you think this would be one of the best Pop-Tarts varities?
Frosted Boston Creme Donut Pop-Tarts
You love or hate these as some reviews read that they are spot on, you get the real donut flavor and feels but others are saying its flavor is bland and they shouldn’t even call these after the Boston creme donuts. This has to be one of the most decadent flavors of all the Pop-Tarts varieties! Would you agree?
Frosted Brown Sugar Cinnamon Pop-Tarts
These Pop Tarts have always been a staple and who doesn’t love the original frosted brown sugar cinnamon? This flavor is so well-loved that people say not to change to OG and that it’s good, hot or cold. Most people seem to love these pop tarts, calling them a yummy classic, the tastiest flavor and even the goat.
Frosted Cherry Pop-Tarts
Overall cherry is one of the best flavors according to one reviewer. Some people say that it isn’t the same as it once was, that it’s almost all crust with barely any filling and even less frosting. When it comes to the flavor though, it’s a taste sensation between fresh cherries and cherry pie filling. A little but sweet and a little bit tart with the pastry and and a sweet frosting on top. Yum! What do you think of cherry as one of the best Pop-Tarts varieties?
Frosted Chocolate Chip Pop-Tarts
The biggest gripe we the people have about these chocolate chip frosted Pop Tarts is that they were discontinued. Kids loved them, adults want to bring them back, and others say they want these to be their go to! A reviewer grabbed a pack of these from the gas station and said they were the greatest and most delicious snacks they had had. Seriously, though. Pop- Tarts, read the reviews and bring these back, we are all waiting!
Frosted Chocolate Fudge Pop-Tarts
These Pop-Tarts varieties are made of chocolate pastry with a chocolate filling and of course a chocolate frosting, triple chocolate if you will. One review commented that this flavor is vile, rancid and downright disgusting. Others say they love all the chocolate in them because, “Anything chocolate, I’m in. Who doesn’t like chocolate?” And shockingly enough, someone said that since the vanilla was discontinued that the chocolate ones are now their go to.
There is a favorite version of Pop-Tarts varieties for everyone! Let me know your favorite flavor in the comments and why it’s s’mores.