- Let me know if you love Oreos enough to try some of these wacky flavors.
Would you try these truly bizarre Oreo flavors? They are pretty strange but could be absolutely delightful!
Cotton Candy
An Oreo with a vanilla cookie and cream that tastes like cotton candy? These cookies came back to the shelf in June 2023. Many Oreo lovers love these cotton candy cookies while others are still waiting for a revival of one of their favorite flavors. What do you think, would you try this truly bizarre Oreo?
Blueberry Pie
The Blueberry Pie Oreo was released in June 2016 and originally was only available at Target. Rave reviews caused this flavor to be rereleased one year later but is exclusive to Cub Foods, Farm Fresh, Hornbacher’s, Shop ‘n Save, and Shoppers.
Apple Cider Donut
The Apple Cider Donut was released prior to the Fall season in August 2021. The vanilla Oreo was filled with a light, sweet and apple-y flavor. This wasn’t the first Fall seasonal cookie that came out though. You can also check out Candy Corn, Caramel Apple, Pumpkin Spice and Apple pie varieties as well.
Pina Colada Thins
When this flavor came out, it was part of the “My Oreo Creation” contest and also up against two other flavors. From the classic cocktail that inspired the cookie, it’s got a layer of coconut creme and pineapple creme between two vanilla cookies. Do you think this should be considered a truly bizarre flavor?
Swedish Fish
Fruity fish, well fruity fish candy, and cookies came together in this mashup. Unfortunately, paired with the original chocolate cookie, some reviewers compared this flavor to cherry cough syrup. Yikes. That was definitely not the taste they were hoping for with this cookie and maybe the most truly bizarre (final) flavor on the list.
Cherry Cola
Cherry Cola won the flavor suggestions in its “My Oreo Creation” contest back in 2018. The Cherry Cola Oreo started with chocolate cookies and the creme was cherry-cola flavored with the addition of popping candy. You know, for the fizz.
Key Lime Pie
The Key Lime Pie Oreo was reinvented in July 2015, with two graham-flavored cookies and a creme layer of key lime. They also returned for a limited time in 2017. Did you know that in Key West, if you order Key Lime Pie, it comes with chocolate? Maybe Oreos will come out with a Key Lime-flavored Oreo with the original chocolate cookies. Do you think you’d like to try this truly bizarre flavor?
Hot and Spicy Cinnamon
In January of 2018, the Hot and Spicy Cinnamon Oreo had chocolate cookies with a cinnamon-flavored creme in the middle. The cinnamon cookies was an absolute smash, depending on who you asked. One reviewer said “The cinnamon shines through without overpowering the cookie,” going as far as calling this flavor “better than the original.” Wow. What a rave! All that being said, would you enjoy trying this truly bizarre Oreo?
Kettle Corn
Starting with the vanilla Oreo cookie, the creme is filled with kettle-flavored creme made with puffed millet pieces. Do you think you’d like this truly Bizarre Oreo flavor?
So what do you think of these Oreo flavors? Let me know in the comments if you would try them! Want to know about more Oreo flavors? Watch for another article, to come!